Farming Freshwater Algae on the High Seas

If you have been paying even the slightest attention to the algae industry, you probably have heard of companies like Solazyme or Synthetic Genomics, the big names that are making big public strides in the field. Algasol Renewables, on the other hand, is one name in the industry that you have probably never heard mentioned. However, Algasol looks to be on the brink of joining those big names as one of leaders in the algae industry with their photobioreactor system.

Photobioreactors (or PBR’s) come in many different shapes, sizes, and designs. Essentially, they consist of some clear material formed in a way that it can hold an algae-containing liquid. Typically, you will find them looking like long tubes, snaking back and forth, that allow sunlight to reach the algae-water concentration that is pumped through it. They work great for growing algae but have typically suffered from high initial and operating costs.

This is where Algasol comes into play. They have designed a photobioreactor system that can potentially cut costs by 90 percent. How have they done this? Well, their thinking has taken them outside the tube and placed them into a bag.

Basically, their system grows freshwater microalgae in large plastic bags that float on top of bodies of saltwater. There, as in any other bioreactor, nutrients and CO2 are pumped in to feed the algae.

This design led Frost & Sullivan to give Algasol their 2010 “Global Algae Biofuels Award.” According to them, “Algasol Renewables provides a critical and innovative method for micro algae biomass production. Its modular floating bag technology, a new variation of photobioreactors (PBRs), provides a low-cost design coupled with industrial scalability, optimal light exposure, high biomass concentration, low energy consumption, and efficient system control.”

The oceans of the world have a great potential to be the location for floating algae farms. First off, oceans cover around 70 percent of the world. With land (especially agricultural land) becoming a very precious commodity, moving production of fuel offshore is a major bonus.

Additionally, the ocean cuts out a lot of the energy costs associated with traditional PBR’s. For example, the water surrounding the bags acts as a temperature buffer, a process that would require spraying down the outsides of the photobioreactor in typical systems. Also, the wave action in the ocean helps to mix the algae in the bags, something that would otherwise take additional energy in land-based designs.

Now, some may be concerned about putting all this plastic into the ocean should a storm comes along or worried about what happens if these bags break. Luckily, engineers at Algasol have addressed both of these problems. If a storm comes along, the bags have been designed to be submerged beneath the water to levels up to 250 feet. There, they can wait out a tropical storm, hurricane, etc.

Researchers are also not too concerned if one of the bags breaks. Since the algae will be freshwater species, they will die when exposed to saltwater and there, researchers have concluded, they can become food for fish and other marine life.

Their system has proven very successful in testing conducted in conjunction with Arizona State University. Right now, after taking account for the costs, they estimate that a 250 hectares (or 418 acres) system can produce oil at $1.40/gallon before refining, or roughly $60 a barrel.

These costs are actually calculated from the lower end of production levels (35 grams of algae per square meter). Algasol has achieved significantly higher production levels and higher productivity would potentially lower the cost even more. However, reaching these production levels rely more on outside factors than on the system itself.

“At the end of the day, we are dealing with a live organism here,” Miguel Verhein, Executive Director of Algasol said. “If this organism is not taken care of under the right conditions, then we can have a variation in productivity that is irrelevant to the photobioreactor system.”

Overall, Algasol is solely a technology company that, according to Verhein, “just wanted to make the best PBR based on CAPEX/OPEX and scalability.” As such, their goal is to sell their patented product and method to companies rather than produce the algae themselves.

This goal is quickly becoming a reality, with several organizations, including one large oil company, looking to purchase their technology. As with algae industry as a whole, all that seems to be required for Algasol to make it big is a little more time.

Source: http://algaenews.com/?p=529

Heterotrophic vs. Photoautotrophic Algae Cultures

In a follow-up to my last post it is my belief that the Canadian government will be much more responsive in assisting the alternative fuels industry based on a climate change approach as opposed to that of energy security. That being said what is the greenest approach to cultivating algae in British Columbia? I put some quick flow charts together outlining the different issues and benefits of these two leading agricultural processes.

Photoautotrophic System
Photobioreactor Environmental Flowchart

Environmental Benefits

  • Recycled industrial CO2 emissions offers algae productivity
  • Decreased land requirements due to increase algae productivity
  • Minimized impact on natural habitats
  • Designed in scalable modules, limited only by CO2 capital/operational costs and land availability
  • Continuous/cascading production allows the cultivation process to continue with less frequent systme shut-downs for cleaning and inoculation

Environmental Concerns

  • Efficient light delivery and distribution are principle obstacles to scale-up
  • Energy demand may be a challenge in bringing this to commercial scale
  • Requires a continuous input of carbon dioxide (energy drain and concentration of heavy metals)
  • Exotic and potentially invasive algal species could threaten the integrity of local and regional ecosystmes, e.g., if escaped through released waste water

Environmental Unknowns

  • Implications of energy demand
  • Very few large-scale closed photobioreactor systems have been implemented, so the feasibility is difficult to ascertain
  • Algae to overcome challenges of efficient cultivation

Heterotrophic System

Environmental Benefits

  • Minimized water usage and management
  • Minimized energy inputs due to high cell densities, low water content, and exclusion of light
  • Reduced landfill by use of cellulosic “wastes” that result in methane emissions
  • Applicable in most climates and regions with limited impact on land use or adjacent ecosystems
  • Scalability is based on a group of feedstock types that are locally available

Environmental Concerns

  • Indirect water burden if feedstock is derived from an irrigated crop
  • Potential for organic substrates on arable land
  • Feedstock could be limited by seasonal availability
  • Organic material processed by energy-intensive hydrolysis before use as a feedstock

Environmental Unknowns

  • The energy imbalance, including inputs
  • Direct and indirect water use data is limited and changes from region to region
  • Potential environmental costs and benefits associated with other green technologies competing for those same waist feed-stocks
  • Some feedstock sources may be more sustainable than others

Environmental Summary

Photobioreactor

Clearly the most significant environmental concern for a Canadian / British Columbian based photobioreactor will be the electrical drain of utilizing a hybrid, solar / artificial illumination system. What is the energy return for the creation of a liquid fuel? Fortunately here in British Columbia we are one of the cleanest provincial / state environments in North America. A significant amount of our electrical energy comes from renewable sources. With the large volumes of CO2 that algae can consume it would be interesting to see just how much this process could further bring down our carbon footprint.

Fermentor

It can be assumed that the electrical consumption of processing the cellulosic waist and maintaining the fermentors will be less than that of the PBRs. The difficulty comes in analyzing the indirect impact associated with the algae feedstock. We know that the CO2 consumed and processed by this feedstock is significantly less than would have been processed directly from the algae in a photobioreactor, but this is not the best way to measure the reduction in greenhouse gas emissions. If this cellulosic waist is left to rot, it will emit methane gas. Methane is believed to be several times more potent than CO2 when it comes to climate change. The difficulty is there is significant debate over how potent it actually is.

In-Closing

There are many other ‘cellulosic waist to energy’ solutions that compete for fermentation feedstock and the key here is big picture environmental reform. Without running both techniques side by side within a specific regional economy it will be difficult to definitively gauge wether one technique has a better environmental benefit to concern ratio over the other. That being said, utilizing PBR technology is going to visibly appear to have much more dramatic environmental benefits because you are redirecting unsightly emissions into algae production. Because alternative fuels need both public and governmental support, if both techniques turn out to be equally financially viable, PBRs definitely have a significant marketing edge. In some upcoming posts I will be conducting an analysis of the economics of Heterotrophic vs. Photoautotrophic Algae Cultivation.

Source: http://www.pacificrimbiodiesel.com/?p=201

Pacific Rim BioEnergy

About Pacific Rim

We are a Canadian West Coast algae start-up that is dedicated to the growth and development of high-quality algae oil and biomass products. Our goal is to achieve commercial production capabilities and establish a distribution network of algae co-products and by-products into new Canadian West Coast markets.

We have assembled a skilled management team with a wide range of background experience and knowledge for the purpose of achieving our goals. If you need to contact our team for employment, investment or partnership opportunities, please visit our contact us page on our official web site. We will attempt to respond in a timely manner.

 

Source: http://www.pacificrimbiodiesel.com/?page_id=2

Alga for Feed Project

The world population growth – World Statistics, and increasing average standard of living, implies an increasing demand on feeds – total world feed output is approximately 614 million tonnes – IFIF Statistics. Animal feed consumption already exceeds direct human food consumption by almost four, and this ratio can only rise as the demand more animal protein increases. The ability to produce increasing amounts of feeds is one of the greatest challenges facing mankind, perhaps even greater than the environmental, energy, global warming and resource crisis. An increase in world population plays an important role on increasing feed demand. For instance, there are currently 6.5 billion people in the world. It is estimated that by 2030 there will be 2 billion more mouths to feed. This world population growth is driving meat consumption, and more meat means more grain … feed demand and animal feed supplements are rising!

Microalgae can play an important role in the future. They are one of the potential sources of foods and feeds provided by Nature with the potential to feed an ever growing and affluent population. Microalgae are the photosynthetic organisms in the first levels of the aquatic food-chains, on which an ever growing part of our food will have to come from. Our challenge is to domesticate these plants, as we have done with higher plants, to allow us to manage their large scale production for a wide range of applications, including feeds.

 

This Brief aims to (1) bring together the most relevant information available on microalgae feed production – and (2) promote the knowledge management to help accelerate the development of algae feeds. We hope that is Brief will contribute for the emergence and expansion of projects and ventures in this sector.

Source: http://www.algae4feed.org/about.php